Life and Times of an Ithaca Baker

The Sophie Fund presented Aušra Milano with a “Lifetime Achievement Award” at the 10th Annual Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest on October 18 in recognition of the outstanding confections she entered every year since the event began in 2016.

Aušra Milano & friend receiving an award at the 2024 Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest

“We are constantly amazed at the creations that she whips up,” said contest emcee Gabriella da Silva Carr. “She uses all manner of unexpected ingredients: anything from black sesame seeds, tahini, and rose water; to cocoa powder, olive oil, and orange zest; to putting blackberries together with orchard apples.”

Carr also noted Milano’s creative decorations. “She has made cupcakes that resemble ice cream cones, and others in the form of a cup of coffee where the cup and saucer are also edible. Her frosting can be an extravagant floral arrangement or a simple-but-spooky Halloween look that she describes as a black-and-white photo.”

Milano always appreciated the mental health theme behind the contest. When the contest had to be held online in 2020 during the Covid-19 pandemic, her entry form noted that many people were dying, struggling, or barely holding on. So that year, Carr explained, Milano created the ice cream cone cupcakes reminiscent of ice cream socials “to remind us of happy, hopeful, and joyful times when all was okay. Or at least seemed okay.”

Carr said that one year Milano submitted brown butter carrot cupcakes—her personal favorite—with a message that reflects the true spirit of the cupcake contest: “Simple, humble cupcakes, nothing too fancy, pure comfort and love.”

Milano called the Lifetime Achievement Award “a wonderful surprise,” adding “I feel truly honored and appreciated, it means a ton to me. I loved to bake since a very early age and that passion still continues.”

Milano said that she baked a lot of goods for various gatherings and events when her sons were in school, but since they graduated she had fewer occasions for her treats.

“That is why I am so happy there is Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest,” she said. “It gives me a chance to think about what could I bake next, an opportunity for me to experiment, be creative, and just get lost in a kitchen for a while. I love the event and have great joy participating every year.”

The thing Milano loves most about the contest, she said, is how many young people are involved.

“Young bakers, volunteers, so many happy smiling youthful faces,” she noted. “I think this brings so much important meaning to the event that is centered around mental health and support.”

Thank You, Cupcake Contest Sponsors!

The Sophie Fund extends its gratitude and heartfelt thanks to Visions Federal Credit Union, Cayuga Health, Well Said Media, Maguire Family of Dealerships, and Wegmans for supporting the 10th Annual Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest. Thank you for once again championing the mental health mission in our community!

Cupcake Joy, 2025 Edition

We’re celebrating 10 years of the Annual Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest! Here’s a slideshow from the latest edition held in the Ithaca Commons on October 18, 2025.

Registration Team for 10th Annual Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest

Madelyne entering her “Pumpkin Chai Cupcakes”

Kirstan Brodie’s “Apple of My Pie Cupcakes”

Jonica LeRoux entering her “Bear Paw’s Smoky Sugar Shack Cupcakes”

Katy Holloway’s “The Pineapple Doesn’t Fall Far from the Tree Cupcakes”

Lucia entering her “Halloween Cupcakes”

Anayeli Newton’s “S’mores Cupcakes”

Bethanie Keem-Calhoun’s “Mimosa Cupcakes”

Rebecca DeGroat entering her “Happy 250th Birthday Marine Corps Cupcakes”

Sadie Hays’s “Mount Merapi Cupcakes”

Kyra O’Toole entering her “Fall Forest Cupcakes”

Hudson, Paxton, and Gamay’s “Harry Potter Cupcakes”

Lydia Mentzer’s “Mexican Hot Chocolate Cupcakes”

Megan Martinez’s “Pumpkin’ed Up Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cupcakes”

Alecia Sundsmo’s “Mexican Hot Chocolate Cupcakes”

Isaac Ortiz’s “Dubai Chocolate Cupcakes”

Tabitha Gray’s “Orange Chocolate Surprise Cupcakes”

Village at Ithaca’s Razzmatazz Rainbow Cupcakes”

Dawn Kracht’s “A Taste of Fall Cupcakes”

Cupcakes awaiting the judges

Juju B’s Sweets’s “Joy Cupcakes”

Travis Bohmer’s “Apple Pie, Oh My! Cupcakes”

Sophie Fund giveaways for the contestants

Sophie Fund volunteers

Event planner Cara Nichols and friends

Awards Ceremony Emcee Gabriella da Silva Carr and sidekick-in-lederhosen Ben Sandberg

Wegmans pastry chefs Savannah and Natalie conduct a cupcake decorating workshop

Mastering the art of piping floral decorations

Wegmans decorating workshop cupcakes ready to eat

Let the judging begin (with a Corgi named Gnocchi standing guard)

So many cupakes, so little time

Drum roll, please, for the final round of judging!

Molly receiving the Autumn Magic Award

Kate Bagnell receiving the 3rd Place Award for her “Cinnamon Roll Cupcakes”

Sadie Hays receiving the Honorable Mention Award for her “Mount Merapi Cupcakes”

Katy receiving the Honorable Mention Award for her “The Pineapple Doesn’t Fall Far from the Tree Cupcakes”

Marina Mahashin and Amin Lopez Luna receiving the Honorable Mention Award for their “Coco-Mango Sticky Rice Cupcakes”

The Sophie Fund Team

Be Kind Ithaca finding new ways to spread the message

And that’s a wrap: “Elvis has left the Pavilion

Ithaca Cupcakes 2025: Special Awards

Contestants in the 10th Annual Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest on October 18 dazzled the judges with their creations! Congratulations to these winners of Special Awards!

Special Awards

The Guac Star Award

Lydia Mentzer

The Sorting Hat Choice Award

Hudson, Paxton, and Gamay

Flavor Bouquet Award

Madelyne Myers

Slice of Pi Award

Kirstan Brodie

Autumn Magic Award

Molly Maher

Spooktacular Sweet Treat Award

Lucia O’Toole

Vivacious Vegan Delight Award

Juju B’s Sweets

Orange Explosion Award

Tabitha Gray

Spirit of Service Award

Rebecca DeGroat

Power in Every Bite Award

Alecia Sundsmo

Sky’s The Limit Award

Village at Ithaca

Lydia Mentzer’s “Mexican Hot Chocolate Cupcakes,” chocolate cakes with guacamole-colored frosting.

Hudson, Paxton, and Gamay’s “Harry Potter Cupcakes,” vanilla sponge cakes with beer-flavored buttercream frosting topped with Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw, and Slytherin scarves and pretzel stick wands.

Madelyne Myers’s “Pumpkin Chai Cupcakes,” pumpkin, ginger, nutmeg, and chocolate cakes, with brown sugar cream cheese frosting.

Kirstan Brodie’s “Apple of My Pie Cupcakes,” cinnamon-spiced cakes studded with juicy apple chunks topped with a “pie crust” of salted brown butter cream cheese frosting.

Molly Maher’s “Between Seasons Cupcakes,” chocolate spice cakes with orange marmalade filling topped with chocolate cream cheese frosting and grated candied orange.

Lucia O’Toole’s “Halloween Cupcakes,” dark chocolate cakes and chocolate frosting with Halloween decorations.

Juju B’s Sweets’s “Joy Cupcakes,” cocoa and apple sauce cakes studded with toasted almonds topped with coconut-flavored frosting, sweetened coconut flakes and almond slivers.

Tabitha Gray’s “Orange Chocolate Surprise Cupcakes,” chocolate cakes with orange filling and an orange buttercream frosting.

Rebecca DeGroat’s “Happy 250th Birthday Marine Corps Cupcakes,” carrot cakes with cream cheese frosting and gold and red sprinkles.

Alecia Sundsmo’s “Mexican Hot Chocolate Cupcakes,” chocolate vegan cakes with chocolate icing and a vegan marshmallow on top.

Village at Ithaca’s “Razzmatazz Rainbow Cupcakes,” blue raspberry confetti cakes and Italian meringue frosting topped with meringue clouds and blue raspberry and sour candy.

Ithaca Cupcakes 2025: Honorable Mention Awards

The Sophie Fund thanks the 25 bakers who entered their showpieces in the 10th Annual Ithaca Cupcake Baking Contest. The judges selected 10 contestants to receive Honorable Mention Awards. Congratulations to all! Honorable Mention awardees were presented with $25 gift certificates from the Downtown Ithaca Alliance.

Honorable Mention

Katy Holloway

Dawn Kracht

Sadie Hays

Megan Martinez

Jonica LeRoux

Anayeli Newton

Bethanie Keem-Calhoun

Isaac Ortiz

Amin Lopez Luna and Marina Mahashin

Travis Bohmer

Katy Holloway’s “The Pineapple Doesn’t Fall Far From the Tree Cupcakes,” upside down pineapple cakes and tart cherry curd filling topped with decadent cocktail cherries under tropical umbrellas in brown-sugar sand.

Dawn Kracht’s “A Taste of Fall Cupcakes,” pumpkin cakes with maple frosting inspired by hikes at Taughannock Falls and other area parks when the temperatures cool and the leaves turn colors.

Sadie Hays’s “Mount Merapi Cupcakes,” purple-black sesame and rice cakes resembling volcanic sand topped by billowy clouds of coconut buttercream frosting with mango-passion fruit curd “lava” centers.

Megan Martinez’s “Pumpkin-ed Up Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cupcakes,” pumpkin cakes filled with cheesecake with a salted caramel Swiss meringue buttercream frosting and vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream flowers.

Jonica LeRoux’s “Bear Paw’s Smoky Sugar Shack Cupcakes,” brown butter vanilla cakes topped with maple frosting, smoky bacon and smoky salt—inspired by memories of a renaissance man making maple from sap.

Anayeli Newton’s “S’mores Cupcakes,” chocolate cakes with Reese’s Peanut Butter chips on a graham cracker crust foundation with toasted marshmallow frosting.

Bethanie Keem-Calhoun’s “Mimosa Cupcakes,” orange and champagne cakes in a sweet champagne cake soak with a strawberry flavored champagne frosting that bubbles to the taste.

Isaac Ortiz’s “Dubai Chocolate Cupcakes,” moist chocolate cakes filled with rich pistachio cream, finished with a pistachio buttercream frosting dusted with chopped pistachios and topped with chocolate-covered strawberries.

Amin Lopez Luna and Marina Mahashin’s “Coco-Mango Sticky Rice Cupcakes,” coconut and mango tres leches soaked sponge with coconut-mango whipped cream frosting and fresh mango and coconut flakes.

Travis Bohmer’s “Apple Pie, Oh My! Cupcakes,” cinnamon-infused cakes with apple pie filling topped with vanilla-apple cinnamon frosting and buttery crumble.